Monday, October 15, 2007

Reasonable Accommodation Hearings: On the creation of a Muslim boogeywoman

On September 28 Christine Pelchat of the Quebec Council on the Status of Women proposed that the provincial government forbid public employees from wearing religious clothing - not only the Muslim headscarf but also the Jewish kippa, though, surprise surprise, crucifixes on necklaces would be ok because they're not immediately visible!

The Council, for those of you from elsewhere, is not a feminist group: it is a government body. Pelchat is a seasoned politician, having served as a Liberal MP in the eighties and early nineties. More recently she was head of staff for the Minister of Public Security at the time that Mohamed Anas Bennis was murdered by Montreal police and then head of staff for the Minister of the Family and the Elderly prior to her current stint at the Quebec Status of Women.

The proposal came a few days after Lise Bourgault's call to ban all religious clothing in any public place at all. Bourgault is a former Conservative Federal MP, currently mayor of the small town of Brownsburg-Chatham about an hour's drive northwest of Montreal. Her statement was full of the geographic anxieties of those outside out of the dynamic metropolitan centers, as she complained of going to the (Greek) Adonis market in Laval and seeing women in veils walking behind their husbands.

Such recommendations are racist, but to just say so is not enough. It's important to take a look at why they are racist. Not least because this racism is framed in anti-sexist terms.

Pelchat for instance preceded her recommendation with the bland proposition that gender equality trumps freedom of religion, which is uncontroversial and correct but seems to have put some people off their guard as to what came next. (How else to explain the fact that Pelchat's words won accolades from NEFAC Quebec City at the same time as they were embraced by provincial premier Jean Charest?)

Pelchat's proposition is racist because she has claimed the right to decide for women of other cultures how to define their own oppression and their own liberation.

In the proper context there is nothing racist with one person telling another their opinion, that they think this or that in their culture is problematic. We all come from fucked up cultures, and most of our cultures are getting more fucked up with every passing year.

But Pelchat is calling upon the State - a State controlled by white men in the service of capitalism - to suppress and repress those immigrant women who disagree with her.

What i find odious is not that she has said gender equality should take precedence over people's religions. It is rather the implication that in order for it to do so her (whitened and enlightened) freedom of conscience should take precedence over that of immigrant women. She'll be the big sister making the call for the wayward little girls who don't know any better.

There's a few aspects of all this i've been mulling over, so after a couple of weeks let's see if i can get them down...

1. Le Québec aux Québecois! (note the masculine...)

This hullabaloo about headscarves is largely a pissing contest to remind folks about who is in charge in Quebec. The headscarf has become a symbol, not of women's status, but of one's relationship to the State and to the "mainstream".

The point is to establish that Quebec has a culture, and that this culture has roots in the Roman Catholic French Canadian experience. Thus churches and crosses are part of "our" heritage. Lipstick and halter tops are part of where "we" are at now. Parts of "our" identity.

Which is why you won't find people like Pelchat banning sexist songs from school kids' ipods, or banning cosmetics or skirts or other gendered pieces of clothing from the civil service. Certainly you won't find the latest sexist production from Hollywood pulled from the province's theaters.

That's because this is a false anti-sexism, a pseudo-feminist fig leaf meant to cover up the real source of anxiety.

(In this regard the anarchist Workers Solidarity Movement were right on the mark when they noted that "For women who freely choose to wear the Islamic headscarf, it can be difficult to take being told you are oppressed for wearing it from a culture where around 5% of all females spend their teens puking over a toilet bowl so that they can look like Kate Moss.")

This concern with defining "our" culture is so pressing because the Quebec economy is increasingly dependent on immigrant labour, both within the formal economy but even more so for social reproduction, as people of colour are filling the gaps created by the feminist revolution of the twentieth century. La revanche du berceau is a double edged sword, and it is no longer sufficient or even relevant whether or not the children of white francophone Quebeckers assimilate or not... for Quebec to persist as a cultural-political entity immigrants need to assimilated into the Nation as quickly and seamlessly as possible.

The flipside to the ongoing de-settlerization (or will it be re-settlerization?) of Quebec and Canada is an increased emphasis on identity, on defining who "we" are, and insisting that others integrate into "us".

That this is felt most strongly by those within the white nations who have reaped the least benefits from imperialism is one of the cruel ironies of capitalism. Of course people living far away from the centers of power feel the most vulnerable. Of course they worry the most about being supplanted by this new proletariat. Of course they holler the loudest.

It is in this context that to not wear hijab - a decision a majority of Muslim women continue to make - is being transformed into a pledge of allegiance. A visible sign that a woman is "ok," is "one of us," or at least is willing to head in our direction. She won't raise her children to challenge "us" for "our" State, "our" economy, "our" cultural hegemony.

& wearing one, in turn, is being transformed into a statement of defiance.

(That this debate centers on women is only logical - it is immigrant women who will play a key role in determining the identity of immigrant children, the proletariat of tomorrow.)

2. Reasonable Accommodation Hearings: Wind in Racist Sails

The reasonable accommodation hearings provide the context behind this crap, and the are a brilliant set-up if i ever saw one.

Just prior to this spring's provincial elections the right-wing ADQ (Quebec Democratic Action) and media outlets decided to play the culture card, fomenting a debate about "reasonable accommodation." The term was stripped of its actual legal meaning, and became shorthand for "immigrant culture" and the perceived erosion of the traditional ethnic pecking order.

There were shock-horror stories about Jews enforcing kosher rules at a Montreal hospital, and forcing a gym to install tinted windows. Others about Muslims getting men banned from birthing classes for pregnant women, or insisting on the gender of driving instructors.

In each case the details proved less scandalous that the demagogues presented them, and in many cases in fact these were reasonable measures taken to accommodate people. Nevertheless, the question had become a political hot potato, and before you could say "kulturkampf" girls were getting banned from sports events for wearing hijab and white folks were up in arms about the few dozen women in Quebec who wear niqab being allowed to vote.

The ruling Liberal party was in a quandry. On the one hand, the Liberals cannot win an election without support from the Quebecois majority, on the other hand the Liberals are the party which maintains absolute hegemony within Quebec's minority communities, and which has the job of integrating these communities within the federalist camp.

The solution was typical: set up a roaming commission headed by two fancy intellectuals to deal with the issue.

Clearly, the Liberals hoped that in so doing the would defuse the ADQ's new hobby horse. Yet from an anti-racist perspective this ploy is bound to fail, in fact it is bound to make things worst.

Let's be clear: when this is all over commissioners Taylor and Bouchard are going to come up with some mildly inoffensive nostrums about tolerance, a "Quebec model" of integration, and the need for greater understanding so that we can all get along. It is conceivable that they wrote - or were given - their final recommendations before the traveling circus even began. The commission is intended to give everyone the appearance of consultation, but really there is not much that is open to debate.

The reason this will make things worst is two-fold.

By setting up a commission on this question the very debate on "reasonable accommodation" is legitimized. As one intervention after another has made clear, everyone knows that this debate is really about the status of immigrants in tomorrow's Quebec. As such, the commission is just a soap-box for xenophobia, making it seem like the position of racists and that of immigrants are somehow equally valid.

Furthermore, the commission will not defuse anything. Once "the people" have had their say and "the eggheads" ignore them, or only pay them lip service, the stage will be set for a new round of demagogy. As long as they remain in opposition the ADQ and Pauline Marois' new "PQ identitaire" will be able to position themselves as the only authentic voices of the people. More worrisome though, this combination of racism and feeling of being ignored by those in power will prepare the ground for the seeds of fascism, of a new round of far right mobilization and organization.

For the moment this may not be such a bad thing so far as the Liberals are concerned. While they are on the defensive, they are still ahead in comparison with the PQ, which was decimated by the rise of the ADQ in the last elections. Now, with PQ leader Pauline Marois' turn towards a nationalism based on "identity", the PQ and ADQ might potentially be played off against each other in subsequent elections - or so the Liberals must be hoping.

Immigrants, people of colour and other "foreigners" will be the only ones with anything to lose.

Or at least that is what i see down the road.



3. Freedom of Religion is a Red Herring


The ADQ, the Liberals and the racist media have all been very careful to frame this debate in terms of "gender equality vs. freedom of religion."

Take a moment to think of why.

Freedom of religion is a strawman. It's something progressive people are used to "supporting" without really thinking about it, the way reformists support all kinds of bourgeois "freedoms", and so it's a bicycle we can be tricked into riding without noticing that both tires are flat.

To be clear: freedom of conscience is an important thing to struggle for. The ability to think things out for yourself and to act on these thoughts is a prerequisite for political action, for radical theory, for revolution and liberation.

Similarly, opposition to racism is vital. Capitalism requires the constant incorporation of subject peoples, of communities which are marked out for proletarianization by way of their putative "racial" identity. And other communities which are slated for privilege on condition that they play the role of overseer. That today we are told it is a matter of culture, and a hundred years ago we were told it was a matter of biology, indicates a change in scientific discourse, not in political facts. Opposing this racism is an essential component of opposing capitalism and all forms of oppression.

But problems arise when these two important values are shoehorned into the concept of "freedom of religion."

Religions are codified collections of rules and beliefs, bearing all the marks of their contradictory histories and struggles, both internal and external. Freedom of religion can be included within freedom of conscience, but on its own it negates it. The former privileges certain beliefs over others, whereas the latter implies that the freedom to believe in god must go hand in hand with the freedom of apostasy and the freedom of blasphemy.

Based on such a narrow freedom, no mobilization against the racist "reasonable accommodation" debate will succeed. Rather, the oppressed will be pitted against each other, or pushed into schizophrenic positions of favouring one aspect of their identity over others (feminist or believer? queer or Muslim? atheist or immigrant?)

The effect of such a false dichotomy will not be to actually support the rights of women, but rather to inhibit people from uncovering the actual relationship between patriarchy, racism and capitalism.

As radicals we have to look at every mobilization as a stepping stone to the next. Until eventually we get to fight for something worth keeping. If today's struggles prepare us for tomorrow's, what kind of preparation is a defense of religious orthodoxy going to prepare us for? Solidarity with whom, and under what conditions?



16 comments:

  1. C'est ça le point, justement, tout le débat sur les «accomodements raisonnables» est un frame up anti-immigrantEs. Dans ce contexte, qu'est-ce que tu pense de ligne de dénonciation du deux poids, deux mesures concernant le catholicisme et de la revendication d'une radicalisation de la laïcité? La CSN, par exemple, propose une charte de la laïcité à l'image de la charte de la langue française. Ça me semble plein de bon sens.

    En passant, j'en parlais aussi à la radio (voir ici, c'est dans la deuxième moitié de l'émission).

    à ciao

    Nicolas

    ReplyDelete
  2. THIS IS SUCH A GOOD POST!
    Do you mind if I include a link to it on my blog for my Friday links?

    ReplyDelete
  3. J'ai un problème avec cet idée de prôné une laïcité ultra.

    Un anti-sexisme ultra, d'accord, mais même là seulement si c'est comblé avec une perspective anti-autoritaire, i.e. ça ne doit pas être à une classe de femmes à définir le cadre de la libération pour toutes les autres.

    Et c'est ça enfin mon problème avec une laïcité ultra: ça brime autant la liberté du pensé que n'importe lequel réligion d'état.

    Ça a l'aire qu'on est d'accord qu'il s'agit d'un frame up anti-immigrantE. Dans ce cas je crois qu'on a un devoir de le dénoncé en tant que tel, pas d'essayer de l'instrumentalisé pour d'autres campagnes, que ce soit de laïcité ou d'autres...

    (p.s. en passant, y-a-t-il une façon de s'abonner à Voix de Faits?)

    ReplyDelete
  4. hi Zeynab,
    glad you like the post - of course you are welcome to repost it on your blog

    ReplyDelete
  5. Je ne le vois pas comme une instrumentalisation. Officiellement, la question soulevée porte sur les "accomodements raisonnables" de nature religieuse. Et de fait, une bonne partie de la population dénonce la paille dans l'oeil du voisin sans voir la poutre qu'elle a dans le sien. C'est juste de bonne guerre d'exiger un peu de cohérance et de pointer vers ce qu'il reste de l'ancienne domination catholique de la société.

    Personnellement, je n'ai aucun problème avec les intégristes de la laïcité. Ce dont il est question c'est de garantir la neutralité de l'État. Moi je suis d'accord que l'État doit être complêtement séparé de la religion et que les fonfons ne devraient pas porter de signes religieux ostentoires (incluant pas de crucifix).

    Je continue de penser que la bonne façon de désarmer les réactionnaires c'est d'attaquer sur le front religieux, de toutes les religions. Ce qui se passe c'est que les réactionnaires instrumentalisent un inconfort légitime --et pas nécessairement réac-- avec le retour du religieux sur la place publique. En ne réagissant pas et en ne soulignant que l'aspect xénophobe du débat, on jette dans les bras des réacs des gens qui ne le sont pas nécessairement...

    Un truc que j'ai trouvé intéressants sur le sujet: Séparation de l'intelligence et de l'État

    Pour Voix de faits, y'est supposé d'y avoir un feed atom quelque part...

    ReplyDelete
  6. Tiens, j'ai repéré le fil d'abonnement: http://voixdefaits.blogspot.com/feeds/posts/default

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  8. download free tax formsMonday, July 28, 2008 5:12:00 PM

    black mold exposureblack mold symptoms of exposurewrought iron garden gatesiron garden gates find them herefine thin hair hairstylessearch hair styles for fine thin hairnight vision binocularsbuy night vision binocularslipitor reactionslipitor allergic reactionsluxury beach resort in the philippines

    afordable beach resorts in the philippineshomeopathy for eczema.baby eczema.save big with great mineral makeup bargainsmineral makeup wholesalersprodam iphone Apple prodam iphone prahacect iphone manualmanual for P 168 iphonefero 52 binocularsnight vision Fero 52 binocularsThe best night vision binoculars here

    night vision binoculars bargainsfree photo albums computer programsfree software to make photo albumsfree tax formsprintable tax forms for free craftmatic air bedcraftmatic air bed adjustable info hereboyd air bedboyd night air bed lowest pricefind air beds in wisconsinbest air beds in wisconsincloud air beds

    best cloud inflatable air bedssealy air beds portableportables air bedsrv luggage racksaluminum made rv luggage racksair bed raisedbest form raised air bedsaircraft support equipmentsbest support equipments for aircraftsbed air informercialsbest informercials bed airmattress sized air beds

    bestair bed mattress antique doorknobsantique doorknob identification tipsdvd player troubleshootingtroubleshooting with the dvd playerflat panel television lcd vs plasmaflat panel lcd television versus plasma pic the bestThe causes of economic recessionwhat are the causes of economic recessionadjustable bed air foam The best bed air foam

    hoof prints antique equestrian printsantique hoof prints equestrian printsBuy air bedadjustablebuy the best adjustable air bedsair beds canadian storesCanadian stores for air beds

    migraine causemigraine treatments floridaflorida headache clinicdrying dessicantair drying dessicantdessicant air dryerpediatric asthmaasthma specialistasthma children specialistcarpet cleaning dallas txcarpet cleaners dallascarpet cleaning dallas

    vero beach vacationvero beach vacationsbeach vacation homes veroms beach vacationsms beach vacationms beach condosmaui beach vacationmaui beach vacationsmaui beach clubbeach vacationsyour beach vacationscheap beach vacations

    bob hairstylebob haircutsbob layeredpob hairstylebobbedclassic bobCare for Curly HairTips for Curly Haircurly hair12r 22.5 best pricetires truck bustires 12r 22.5

    ReplyDelete
  9. (天正)北京搬家公司,诚实信誉,管理科学化,网络化;员工训练有素,经验丰富,工作细心,服务热情;搬家公司网点分布科学,司机稳重速度!愿为北京搬家的朋友提供优质的搬家服务。订车电话:400-896-0123




    北京飞龙搬家公司,是一家专业性北京搬家公司,企业诚信,员工搬运专业,是北京搬家公司行业的后起新秀,公司长期为搬家用户免费提供纸箱。欢迎重询!




    公兴上海搬场公司是经上海市工商,税务,交通部注册的一家专业性的上海搬家公司,诚实信誉,员工训练有素,经验丰富,工作细心,服务热情;为上海搬场,上海搬家的企业,家庭提供周到服务,如有需求,敬请垂询本搬场公司



    北京海胜数码快印有限公司,致力于数码印刷,诚实信誉,实力雄厚,技术专业,设备先进,设计新颖,是北京数码印刷行业中新秀一支,愿做北京数码快印需求者的忠诚合作伙伴!欢迎广大企业事位来电来涵洽谈,荣幸之致!




    北京华夏国际机票预定中心,全程代理各航机票,特价机票,特价国际机票,北京机票,北京特价机票,北京特价国际机票,留学生机票,打折机票,打折的价格,增值的服务,精心哈护你的远航!

    北京佳佳乐月嫂服务中心,精心提供月嫂服务,育儿嫂服务,育婴师服务,本中心月嫂,育儿嫂,育婴师,均通过健康体验,经过严格培训,持证上岗。经验多,文凭高,端正秀丽,性行淑均,试用之于昔日,客户称之"能用"。



    星云科技,诚信于教育;愿为阶梯,甘为基石;沤心沥血,研究出电子起电机,语音室,语言实验室,数字探究实验室,数字化实验室,探究实验室,系列探究实验配套设施,望广大院校前来考察!




    北京大型圣诞树预定中心,厂家销售,工艺精美,设计科学,可来样加工各种超高圣诞树,松针圣诞树,光纤圣诞树,欢迎前来咨询订购!



    北京婚纱摄影工作室,个性的婚纱,礼服设计,一流的婚纱,礼服设计人才,国际流行风格婚纱礼服的设计理念以及个性婚纱摄影的强力整合;力争成为中国最大的婚纱礼服定做机构!




    投资小见效快!适合小本创业者做的好项目,选择好项目,成功当老板!抢占好商机,等于成功一半,移动鼠标,快快行动!让财富排行榜里有你的一席之地!



    投影机作为一种演示工具,已经得到广泛的运用,如何选购投影机?如何选购投影仪?如何买到最低价格的投影机?本站可为您提供详细参考!




    中关村在线打印机频道,是国内打印机产品最权威的资讯平台,为您提供及时的条码打印机,证卡打印机新闻资讯,最新的打印机报价,全国各地的打印机厂商,强大的打印机论坛互动平台。




    随着激光技术的不断发展,激光打标机设备已广泛应用于服装皮革,工艺礼品,广告标牌,建筑模型,印刷雕版,剪纸包装,石材影雕,木器竹器,电子电器,手机通讯,钟表眼镜,五金,汽车配件等行业。企业外发激光加工艺成为一种趋势,由此本公司与顶级的激光打标机服生产商合作,共同服务于打标领域,从事专业的激光打标服务。在保证服务品质基础上,由于自主的专业生产线,无中间服务商,故此,为客户提供具有优良性价比的激光打标服务。




    喷码机是运用带电的墨水微粒,由高压电场偏转的原理,在各种物体表面上喷印上图案文字和数码,是集机电一体化的高科技产品。产品广泛应用于食品工业,化妆品工业,医药工业,汽车等零件加工行业,电线电缆行业,铝塑管行业,烟酒行业以及其他领域,该机机可用于喷印生产日期,批号,条型码以及商标图案,防伪标记和中文字样,是贯彻卫生法和促进包装现代化强有力的设备。




    扫描仪按不同的标准可以分成不同的类型。按照扫描原理,可以将扫描仪划分为平板式扫描仪,手持式扫描仪和滚筒式扫描仪;按照可扫描的图像的幅面大小,可以分为小幅面扫描仪,中幅面扫描仪,宽幅扫描仪;按照扫描涂图稿的介质分,可以分为反射式扫描仪和透射式扫描仪以及多用途扫描仪;按照用途划分,可以分为通用扫描仪和专用扫描仪。目前一般办公用的扫描仪多为平板式,A4幅面(或A4幅面加长型)扫描仪。




    液晶显示器即LCD,是显示器高新技术的尖端产品,健康环保,低消耗,低辐射,轻巧时尚等,是传统影像显示器所无法相比的,被称为未来显示器市场的发展方向。




    液晶电视的构造简单地说,就是用2块特殊的玻璃夹住液晶体,通过8比特驱动电路和高效背灯系统来调节成像的,这样就使我们传统概念中的电视机超薄型化成为可能。




    与传统的显像管相比,液晶电视信号不失真,视觉不疲劳,没有射线造成的健康损害。节约能源,耗电量是同样大小尺寸显像管电视机耗电量的62%。寿命长,采用新开发的长寿命液晶背灯,实现了可长达60000小时的使用时间,大约可以使用10年(按照每天使用16小时计算)而不用更换。而液晶本身的寿命会比人的寿命还长。又薄又轻,30英寸的显像管电视机重约70公斤,而28英寸的液晶电视才重达16.8公斤。清晰度高,基本不反光。




    北凝科技,成立于1995年,废汽,余热回收,热力除氧改造,凝结水治理专家,其推出的,定连排,烟囱余热回收器,乏汽回收,低位热力除氧器,凝结水回收器,冷凝水,等系列产品技术被定为国际先进成套技术,属于高效节能产品,由国家环保总局确定为国家重点环保技术项目,由科技部列入国家级火炬计划,为社会降低供热成本,提高产品质量,保护大气环境,造福于社会,做出了卓越的供献。




    佳洁士北京保洁公司,北京保洁行业中最具规模的保洁公司,北京2007保洁行业协会优秀保洁公司,竭诚以专业的保洁技术为北京各界提供周到的保洁服务,公司资质齐全,收费合理,设备先进在北京各区县均设有网点,能快速响应客户的不同需要!




    北京特种胶带生产基地,主要生产特种精细胶胶带系列产品。布基胶带,尼龙搭扣胶带,泡棉胶带,耐高温胶带,警示胶带,海绵胶带,耐高温胶带,封箱胶带,屏蔽胶带,印字胶带,美纹纸胶带,高温美纹纸胶带,高压防水胶带,压纹保护胶带,三文治胶带,牛皮纸胶带,阻燃胶带,明兰保护胶带,高尔夫球头保护胶带,玻璃布胶带,双面胶带,文具胶带,矽胶马拉胶带,防爆胶带,箱包胶带,铝箔胶带,电气胶带,BOPP包装胶带,聚脂基胶带。公司将以一流的管理,一流的创新,诚信经营,以优良的品质,优惠的价格,优质的服务,竭诚欢迎新老客户广泛合作,互惠互利,双赢双收,共创锦秀前程,共图宏伟大业.




    郑州国际机票预定中心,各航机票一级代理商服务商,可全程办理各航特价机票,特价国际机票,留学生机票,电子机票,公司诚实信誉,实力雄厚,服务热情,反应快捷,欢迎重询!

    非主流时尚潮流网
    非主流美女
    非主流帅哥
    非主流服饰
    非主流发型
    非主流饰品
    时尚
    时尚发型
    时尚人物
    时尚生活
    时尚潮流
    时尚潮流品牌
    时尚潮流服饰
    个性图片
    个性头像
    图片
    qq空间
    可爱图片
    青年网!
    新势力时尚社区论坛
    新势力时尚社区论坛
    美女
    帅哥
    时尚服饰
    时尚发型
    闪图
    音乐
    个性图片
    图片制作教程
    flash模块
    图片模块
    ps教程
    QQ空间
    QQ网名
    QQ情侣网名
    QQ个性签名

    ReplyDelete
  10. p情趣用品,情趣用品,情趣用品,情趣用品,情趣用品,情趣用品,情趣,情趣,情趣,情趣,情趣,情趣,情趣用品,情趣用品,情趣,情趣,A片,A片,A片,A片,A片,A片,情趣用品,A片,情趣用品,A片,情趣用品,a片,情趣用品

    A片,A片,AV女優,色情,成人,做愛,情色,AIO,視訊聊天室,SEX,聊天室,自拍,AV,情色,成人,情色,aio,sex,成人,情色

    免費A片,美女視訊,情色交友,免費AV,色情網站,辣妹視訊,美女交友,色情影片,成人影片,成人網站,H漫,18成人,成人圖片,成人漫畫,情色網,日本A片,免費A片下載,性愛

    情色文學,色情A片,A片下載,色情遊戲,色情影片,色情聊天室,情色電影,免費視訊,免費視訊聊天,免費視訊聊天室,一葉情貼圖片區,情色視訊,免費成人影片,視訊交友,視訊聊天,言情小說,愛情小說,AV片,A漫,AVDVD,情色論壇,視訊美女,AV成人網,成人交友,成人電影,成人貼圖,成人小說,成人文章,成人圖片區,成人遊戲,愛情公寓,情色貼圖,色情小說,情色小說,成人論壇


    情色文學,色情小說,情色小說,色情,寄情築園小遊戲,情色電影,aio,av女優,AV,免費A片,日本a片,美女視訊,辣妹視訊,聊天室,美女交友,成人光碟

    視訊聊天室,聊天室,視訊,,情色視訊,視訊交友,視訊交友90739,免費視訊,免費視訊聊天,視訊聊天,UT聊天室,聊天室,美女視訊,視訊交友網,豆豆聊天室,A片,尋夢園聊天室,色情聊天室,聊天室尋夢園,成人聊天室,中部人聊天室,一夜情聊天室,情色聊天室,080中部人聊天室,080聊天室,美女交友,辣妹視訊

    ReplyDelete